Zane Michalle
Christa Pike is one name linked with one of Tennessee’s most horrific crimes ever. Convicted of the gruesome murder of Colleen Slemmer in 1995, Christa Pike became the youngest woman to be sentenced to death at that time in the United States. Christa Pike is still the only woman convicted of death in Tennessee, and her offense is still very infamous for its brutality and because the cases against her are still pending.
The Murder
On January 1995, a young 18-year-old Christa Pike committed a crime that shocked the United States. Along with her two coconspirators, Tadaryl Shipp and Shadolla Peterson, Christa Pike lured 19-year-old Colleen Slemmer to an isolated area in Knoxville, Tennessee. The gang was part of a Job Corps program, which is a Federally sponsored education and vocational training program for the youth. The perpetrators maintained that Christa Pike thought Slemmer was attempting to steal her boyfriend Tadaryl Shipp. Jealousy motivated this ghastly sequence of events.
On January 12, 1995, Christa Pike and associates led Slemmer to a remote location on the agricultural campus of the University of Tennessee. In 30 minutes, Pike tortured Slemmer, carved a pentagram on her chest, and finally smashed her brains in with a piece of asphalt. Not just the crime was brutal, but also the fact that Pike seemed unrepentant over it. She even kept a part of Slemmer’s skull as a memento, which later became useful evidence against her.
Read Also: King Von Autopsy: The Controversy Surrounding His Death
Arrest and Trial
Christa Pike was brought in a few days later, two days after the murder. She was boasting about committing the crime with some other Job Corps students. When police officials came to question her for the crime, they found Colleen Slemmer’s part of the skull in Pike’s jacket. Because of this piece of evidence and Pike’s confession, the case built against them by the prosecution was incredibly strong.
On March 1996, Christa Pike was convicted of first-degree murder and sentenced to death. Her accomplice at age 17 was sentenced to life imprisonment. Shadolla Peterson’s role in the crime was minor, and she was let off with probation.
It was not only the brutality of the crime that convinced the jury when it sentenced Christa Pike to death, but also her demeanor while and after murder itself. Lacking remorse, bragging of this act alongside other reasons left little room for mercy within the courts.
Life on Death Row
Christa Pike has been on Tennessee’s death row for nearly 30 years, which makes her one of the longest-serving inmates under a sentence of death. Her prison life is not without scandal. In 2001, Pike attacked another prisoner, Patricia Jones, with a shoe. The attack was so vicious that Jones almost died from the assault. This only added to the notion that Pike is still a threat, even in prison.
Appeals and legal motions have been legion in Pike’s case. In this context, her attorneys over time have filed several pleas for clemency by arguing that she cannot be executed for a host of grounds: her age at the time of the murders, the trauma of her childhood, and most recently, insanity. In appealing on one of the grounds of a claim that she is insane – Pike’s attorneys have argued that abuse and neglect render her incapable of conscious acts of violence, yet the courts have repeatedly overturned that verdict and upheld the death sentence.
Christa Pike Appeals and In-Court Battles
Since her conviction, Christa Pike’s legal team has filed numerous appeals trying to get the sentencing overruled. One of the core arguments in her defense is that she was just 18 at the time when she committed the crime. They argue that considering the fact that Christa Pike was only 18 and subsequently did not receive a sentence of death, since this could have been rendered because of her age. Moreover, mental illness is argued by her counsel to exempt her from suffering a sentence of death.
It is the judgment that was confirmed by the Tennessee Supreme Court against Christa Pike in 2020. The appeal by Christa had been rejected by the court, but her legal team is still fighting for her life; appeals are still in. On the other hand, death penalty cases can take decades or more time to settle with a final judgment, as shown in the case of Christa Pike. The date for execution for Christa Pike has not been set and is not known when that could be.
Public Reaction
Christa Pike’s case has been of great public interest for so many years. So many people are astonished at the brazen nature of the crime and seem to think that she deserved the death penalty. Others believe that there is no room for the death penalty and certainly not for someone as young as she at the time of committing the crime. Discussions surrounding Pike’s case also involved a type of focal point about the death penalty and its use on women.
Over a century has elapsed since Tennessee executed a woman, making Christa Pike’s case especially unique. She is the only female prisoner in Tennessee’s death row. Such is a thing that complicates the debate regarding Christa’s sentence.
The story of Christa Pike was one marked by violence, jealousy, and tragedy as she committed such a heinous murder of Colleen Slemmer in 1995, leaving a dark mark on the history of legal affairs in Tennessee. To this day, Christa Pike is still the only female convict in death row in the state of Tennessee, and her fate is yet to be confirmed since ongoing legal cases. The case’s duration is already long enough as it elapsed decades but still endures as a strong reminder about consequences for actions through the doing of violence and the complexity of the justice system.
Because of her life on death row, appeals that never seem to end, and the highly divisive public opinion surrounding her sentence, the story of Christa Pike is sure to go unfinished for a long time to come. Will she be executed? It remains to be seen, but this much is known: the case of Christa Pike will continue to stir debate for generations to come.
GIPHY App Key not set. Please check settings